At one point or another:

1. Ben Affleck
2. Nicolas Cage
3. Will Smith
4. Matt Damon
5. Johnny Depp
6. Colin Farrell
7. James Franco
8. Jude Law
9. Paul Walker
10. Josh Hartnett
11. Paul Walker
12. Ashton Kutcher
13. Bendan Fraser
14. Matthew Bomer
15. Jerry O'Connell
16. James Marsden
17. Jason Behr
18. Henry Cavill
19. Jared Padalecki

Source